Home insurance companies in Florida have been known to underpay claims in certain cases. It is not uncommon for insurers to find ways to limit the amount they need to pay for claims, sometimes by arguing that the damage is not covered by the policy or by alleging the homeowner did not properly maintain their property.

In recent years, Florida's property insurance legislation has been criticized for potentially encouraging insurance companies to delay and underpay claims. This has raised concerns among homeowners, who may face challenges pursuing adequate compensation for property damage.Florida Residential and Property Storm Damage Insurance Lawyer | Williams Law

Seeking legal advice from experienced professionals specializing in home insurance claims can benefit homeowners who believe their claims have been underpaid or wrongfully denied.

Profit Motive

Insurance companies are businesses; their primary goal is maximizing profits like any business. Paying out large claim settlements can
significantly impact their bottom line. As a result, some insurers may attempt to underpay or minimize claims to safeguard their profitability.

Policy Interpretation

Insurance policies are complex documents filled with legal terms and provisions. There can be ambiguity in certain policy language, allowing insurance adjusters to interpret it in a way that favors the company rather than the policyholder. This flexibility can allow insurers to underpay or deny claims based on their interpretation.

Underestimating Damage

Insurance adjusters are responsible for assessing the damage and determining the claim's value. However, in some cases, they may underestimate the true cost and extent of the damage. This can result in a lower payout than what is needed to repair or replace the damaged  property fully.

Depreciation and Wear and Tear

Insurance policies often consider depreciation and wear and tear when determining claim payouts. This means that older items or materials may be valued less, considering their age and condition. Insurers may use this as a justification to underpay for repairing or replacing damaged items.

Disputed Coverage

Sometimes, disputes arise between the homeowner and the insurance company over the coverage for a specific type of damage. Insurance policies have exclusions and limitations, and insurers may argue that certain types of damage are not covered. This disagreement can result in the denial or underpayment of the claim.

Inadequate Documentation

Insufficient documentation can weaken a homeowner's claim and allow the insurer to underpay. It is crucial for homeowners to properly document the extent of the damage with photographs, repair estimates, and expert opinions. Lack of evidence can give insurers a reason to undervalue the claim.

Delaying Tactics

Insurance companies may intentionally delay the claims process, knowing it puts pressure on homeowners. Financial strain and the need for immediate repairs can force homeowners to accept a lower settlement than they deserve. By prolonging the process, insurers disadvantage the policyholder and increase the likelihood of underpayment.

Protecting Yourself as a Homeowner

While insurance companies have a duty to act in good faith and honor their policy agreements, homeowners can take proactive steps to protect their interests:

Thoroughly Understand Your Policy

Familiarize yourself with your insurance policy's terms, conditions, exclusions, and coverage limits. Seek clarification from your insurer or consider consulting an attorney if needed.

Document Everything

Maintain detailed damage records, including photographs, estimates, and receipts for repairs and replacements. This documentation will support your claim and help prevent underpayment.

Engage with Experienced Insurance Lawyers

An attorney can review your home insurance policy in detail to identify any coverage limitations or exclusions that might have contributed to an underpaid or denied claim. They can also identify any policy endorsements that could be in your favor. While the underpayment of property damage claims can be frustrating, homeowners should not give up easily. Dealing with insurance companies can be challenging, especially regarding home insurance claims. Insurance companies are vested in minimizing claim payouts and often have teams of experienced adjusters and lawyers working on their behalf. In such cases, it's crucial to level the playing field and have a professional advocate for your rights.

Has Your Home Insurance Company Denied or Undervalued Your Property Damage Claim in Florida?

If your insurance company is dragging its feet regarding your property damage claim, you should speak with an experienced insurance claim lawyer as soon as possible. Please contact us online or call our Florida law office directly at 800.451.6786 to schedule your free consultation. We help Florida residents just like you fight the big insurance companies who fail to abide by their own policies. Remember, we work on a contingent basis, meaning you don't pay us anything until we win your case. 

K.C. Williams III
Managing Partner who has spent his entire career representing Florida insurance and personal injury claims.