What Is An Insurance Breach Of Contract In Florida?
practice area bg MOBILE practice area bg scaled

What Is An Insurance Breach Of Contract In Florida?

An insurance breach of contract occurs when an insurance company fails to fulfill an enforceable obligation under a valid insurance policy. In Florida, this may include wrongfully denying a covered property damage claim, underpaying covered losses, or refusing to pay insurance benefits owed under the policy.

When you purchase homeowners or commercial property insurance, you enter into a legally binding contract with your insurance company. In exchange for paying premiums, the insurer agrees to provide coverage for specified losses, subject to the policy’s terms, conditions, exclusions, limitations, and deductibles.

However, not every denied, delayed, or underpaid insurance claim constitutes a breach of contract. To establish a breach, a policyholder generally must show that a valid insurance contract existed, the insurer failed to fulfill a contractual obligation, and the policyholder suffered damages as a result.

An insurance company’s decision to deny coverage or limit payment does not necessarily mean it has fulfilled its obligations under your policy. An experienced Florida property insurance claim lawyer can evaluate the insurer’s decision, identify potential contractual violations, and determine whether legal action may be appropriate to recover unpaid insurance benefits.

What Are Common Examples of Property Insurance Breach of Contract?

An insurance company may breach its contract when it fails to pay covered losses or otherwise refuses to fulfill obligations required by the insurance policy. These disputes frequently arise when Florida homeowners or business owners disagree with their insurers about coverage, repair costs, or the amount of insurance benefits owed.

Common examples of property insurance breach of contract include:

  • Wrongfully denied insurance claims: Refusing to provide coverage for hurricane, wind, water, fire, roof, or other property damage that is covered under the policy.
  • Underpaid property insurance claims: Paying less than the amount contractually owed for covered repairs, restoration, or replacement costs.
  • Improperly applied policy exclusions: Denying coverage based on exclusions or limitations that do not apply to the circumstances of the loss.
  • Failure to pay covered insurance benefits: Withholding payments required under the policy despite the policyholder satisfying applicable claim obligations.
  • Disputes over necessary repair costs: Refusing to pay for covered structural repairs, building materials, or replacement expenses supported by the policy and available evidence.
  • Failure to honor contractual obligations: Refusing to perform an enforceable duty specifically required under the insurance agreement.

For example, an insurance company may acknowledge that a hurricane damaged a homeowner’s roof but approve only minor repairs despite evidence supporting the need for more extensive covered work. If the insurer fails to pay the benefits required under the policy, the dispute may support a breach-of-contract claim.

Similarly, a commercial property insurer may approve building repairs while improperly withholding payments for covered equipment damage, destroyed inventory, or business interruption losses.

The central question is not simply whether the policyholder disagrees with the insurer’s decision, but whether the insurance company failed to perform an obligation required under the contract.

Can an Insurance Company Breach Its Contract by Delaying Payment?

Yes. An insurance company may breach its contract by improperly withholding or delaying payment of benefits owed under the policy. However, not every delay constitutes a breach of contract, and a missed statutory deadline does not automatically establish contractual liability.

Under Florida Statute § 627.70131, property insurers generally must pay or deny an initial, reopened, or supplemental property insurance claim, or a portion of the claim, within 60 days after receiving notice, subject to applicable statutory exceptions and circumstances that may extend or pause the deadline.

Florida law also establishes requirements concerning claim acknowledgments, investigations, inspections, and explanations of coverage decisions. Qualifying late payments may be subject to statutory interest.

However, Florida law distinguishes between violating a statutory claim-handling requirement and breaching an insurance contract. A missed payment deadline does not, by itself, establish that the insurance company breached the policy or create an independent private cause of action.

A breach-of-contract claim may arise when the insurer fails to pay benefits contractually owed, improperly withholds covered payments, or otherwise fails to perform an enforceable obligation.

If your insurer continues to delay payment for covered property damage, a Florida property insurance claim attorney can review the policy, the claim history, and determine whether the insurer’s actions warrant legal action.

What Is the Difference Between Insurance Breach of Contract and Bad Faith in Florida?

The primary difference between insurance breach of contract and insurance bad faith is the legal duty the insurance company allegedly violated. Breach of contract involves failing to fulfill obligations under the insurance policy, while insurance bad faith involves conduct that violates applicable statutory standards for handling insurance claims.

An insurance breach of contract may occur when an insurer wrongfully denies coverage, underpays covered property damage, or refuses to provide benefits required under the policy. The focus is whether the insurance company complied with its contractual obligations.

Insurance bad faith concerns an insurer’s conduct in evaluating, handling, and resolving claims. Under Florida Statute § 624.155, certain bad-faith claims may arise when an insurer fails to attempt in good faith to settle a claim when, under the circumstances, it could and should have done so while acting fairly and honestly toward its policyholder.

However, a wrongful denial, inadequate settlement offer, or breach of contract does not automatically establish insurance bad faith. Bad-faith claims involve additional legal requirements and statutory procedures.

Florida also imposes specific restrictions on property insurance bad-faith lawsuits. Under Florida Statute § 624.1551, a claim for extracontractual damages under § 624.155(1)(b) generally requires a prior court determination that the property insurer breached the insurance contract and entry of a final judgment or decree against the insurer.

What Should You Do If Your Insurance Company Breaches Its Contract?

If you believe your insurance company has breached its contract by wrongfully denying coverage, underpaying your property damage claim, or withholding benefits owed under your policy, consult an experienced Florida property insurance claim lawyer before accepting the insurer’s decision.

An insurance company’s denial letter, repair estimate, or settlement offer does not necessarily reflect the full extent of coverage or benefits available under your policy.

To protect your rights, preserve your insurance policy, declarations page, claim correspondence, photographs of the damage, inspection reports, contractor estimates, repair invoices, and records of insurance payments.

Review the insurer’s explanation for denying or limiting coverage, including the policy provisions and exclusions cited to justify its decision. Avoid signing a final settlement release without understanding whether it could prevent you from pursuing additional benefits. An ordinary undisputed claim payment does not necessarily prevent a supplemental claim.

A Florida property insurance claim attorney can evaluate whether the insurer has failed to fulfill its contractual obligations, investigate disputed coverage decisions, and determine whether negotiation, litigation, or another dispute resolution process is appropriate.

Before accepting a denied or underpaid insurance claim, contact Williams Law Association, P.A.